Choosing the right dog toy can be surprisingly challenging. Many pet owners struggle to find toys that are both safe and engaging, while also holding up to daily play and chewing. The wrong choice can lead to messes, boredom, or even damaged furniture.
This guide highlights the best new dog toys for a variety of needs, from interactive balls to plush squeakers and durable chews. Whether you have a gentle puppy or a determined chewer, you’ll find clear recommendations and practical advice to help you select the perfect toy for your furry friend.
Top 6 New Dog Toys
Choosing the right New Dog Toys can be confusing, so we compared the most popular options and narrowed it down to the best ones for you.
1. Best Pet Supplies Duck Crinkle Squeaky Plush Toy
Small dogs and puppies often need toys that are gentle on their teeth but still engaging enough to keep them entertained. Lightweight plush toys like this one offer a satisfying crinkle and squeak without being too tough for delicate mouths.
This duck-shaped crinkle toy is ideal for smaller breeds or gentle chewers who love interactive play. Its no-stuffing design means less mess, making it a practical choice for pet owners who value easy cleanup and a tidier home.
- No-stuffing construction keeps play areas clean and reduces choking hazards
- Reinforced fabric and stitching add durability for longer-lasting fun
- Puppy-friendly size and shape makes it easy for small dogs to carry and toss
Compared to traditional plush toys with stuffing, this model prioritizes mess-free play and gentle engagement. The tradeoff is that it's not intended for aggressive chewers or larger dogs who need more robust toys.
- Lightweight and easy to carry
- No stuffing for less mess
- Gentle on teeth and gums
- Bright, engaging design
- Durable stitching
- Not for aggressive chewers
- Limited to small or medium dogs
2. Best Pet Supplies Octopus Squeaky Crinkle Dog Toy
Dogs can get bored quickly with toys that offer only one type of stimulation. Multi-sensory toys help keep pets engaged and mentally active, which is especially important for indoor dogs.
This octopus toy combines squeakers and crinkle material in a plush, colorful package. It's designed for dogs who enjoy a mix of sounds and textures during play, making it a great choice for both puppies and older dogs who need extra stimulation.
- Multiple stimulation points: Squeaker in the head and crinkle in the legs for varied play
- Soft plush material: Comfortable for cuddling as well as active play
- Bright, engaging colors: Increases visual interest and excitement
Unlike basic plush toys, this octopus offers a richer sensory experience. However, its plush build may not withstand determined chewers who require tougher materials.
- Squeaker and crinkle for variety
- Soft enough for cuddling
- Encourages interactive play
- Suitable for all ages
- Bright, playful design
- Not ideal for heavy chewers
- May wear out with rough play
3. PetDroid Interactive Motion-Activated Dog Ball
Active dogs often need toys that move on their own to keep them entertained, especially when owners are busy. Traditional balls can lose their appeal if your dog is left to play alone.
The PetDroid Interactive Ball responds to your dog's touch with rolling and bouncing modes, offering unpredictable movement and flashing lights. This makes it a strong option for dogs who love to chase and interact with their toys, both indoors and outdoors.
- Motion-activated play: Rolls or bounces when touched to keep dogs engaged
- USB rechargeable: Convenient charging for repeated use
- Water-repellent build: Suitable for indoor and outdoor environments
Compared to standard fetch balls, this toy emphasizes self-activated play and extended engagement. The main tradeoff is that it's not suitable for aggressive chewers and may be less durable on rough surfaces.
- Self-moving for solo play
- Rechargeable battery
- Flashing lights for added fun
- Includes tennis cover
- Works on multiple surfaces
- Not for aggressive chewers
- Limited runtime per charge
4. Multipet Mini Lamb Chop Plush Squeak Toy
Classic plush toys are a staple for dogs who love to cuddle and squeak their favorite companions. Many dogs develop a strong attachment to soft toys, making them a comforting presence during downtime or play.
The Multipet Mini Lamb Chop stands out for its extra-soft exterior and nostalgic design, making it a go-to for dogs who prefer gentle play and snuggling. It's especially well-suited for smaller breeds and puppies who aren't heavy chewers.
- Soft plush exterior encourages cuddling and comfort
- Built-in squeaker adds interactive play value
- Compact 10-inch size fits small and medium dogs well
Unlike tougher chew toys, this plush prioritizes softness and comfort. The main tradeoff is lower durability for dogs who like to chew aggressively.
- Super soft and cuddly
- Classic, familiar design
- Fun squeaker inside
- Ideal for gentle play
- Good for puppies
- Not for strong chewers
- May wear out with rough use
5. Best Pet Supplies Interactive Squeaky Dog Chew Toy
Dogs that enjoy playing with others or in family settings need toys that are versatile and engaging for multiple participants. Many plush toys are designed only for solo play, limiting their appeal during group activities.
This interactive squeaky toy features crinkle material and a plush build, making it suitable for tossing, tugging, and shared play. It's a solid choice for households with more than one dog or for owners who like to join in the fun.
- Crinkle and squeak design: Multiple sound elements for interactive play
- Plush construction: Comfortable for tugging and carrying
- Bright, engaging colors: Appeals to both dogs and owners
Compared to single-purpose plush toys, this option supports more dynamic play. The tradeoff is that it may not last as long with heavy chewers or very rough play.
- Great for interactive play
- Multiple sound textures
- Soft and comfortable
- Easy to toss and tug
- Fun for group activities
- Not chew-proof
- May wear with heavy use
6. WOOF Pupsicle Long-Lasting Interactive Dog Toy
Treat-dispensing toys can keep dogs occupied and mentally stimulated, but many are difficult to clean or create unwanted messes. This can be frustrating for owners who want a tidy home and a happy pet.
The WOOF Pupsicle is designed for easy filling and cleaning, with a weighted base to prevent tipping and drool-catching slots to minimize mess. It's ideal for dogs who need longer-lasting distraction and for owners who value quick cleanup.
- Easy-open design: Simplifies filling and cleaning after use
- Weighted, no-tip base: Reduces spills and keeps play area clean
- Natural rubber construction: Safe and durable for most dogs
Unlike traditional treat balls, the Pupsicle focuses on hassle-free maintenance and extended playtime. The main tradeoff is that treat refills are sold separately, and it may not satisfy dogs who prefer plush or squeaky toys.
- Simple to fill and clean
- Minimizes mess during play
- Durable natural rubber
- Long-lasting distraction
- Dishwasher safe
- Refills sold separately
- Not a plush or squeaker
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Dog Toy
Dog toys come in a wide range of types and materials, each offering unique benefits and tradeoffs. The right choice depends on your dog's size, chewing habits, and play preferences. Many buyers assume all toys are equally durable or engaging, but subtle differences can make a big impact on safety, cleanup, and your dog's enjoyment.
- Plush toys: Soft and comforting, best for gentle chewers and cuddling
- Squeaky/crinkle toys: Add sound and texture for extra engagement, but may wear out faster with rough play
- Treat-dispensing toys: Provide mental stimulation and longer distraction, but require cleaning and supervision
- Motion-activated toys: Encourage solo play and exercise, but may not suit all surfaces or heavy chewers
- Chew-focused toys: Built for durability and dental health, ideal for strong chewers but less interactive
- Multi-pack sets: Offer variety and value for puppies, but individual toys may be smaller or less robust
- Durability vs. engagement: Tougher toys last longer but may be less stimulating; softer toys are more fun but less durable
- Size and breed fit: Always match toy size and toughness to your dog's breed and chewing style
- Cleaning and maintenance: Some toys are machine washable or dishwasher safe, others require hand cleaning
- Supervision needs: No toy is truly indestructible; supervise play, especially with new or aggressive chewers
Choosing Between Plush, Chew, and Interactive Toys
Each dog has unique play needs. Plush toys are great for comfort and gentle play, while chew toys are best for dogs that need to gnaw. Interactive and motion-activated toys keep dogs busy when you're not available to play. Consider your dog's habits and energy level before choosing.
- Gentle chewers: Plush and squeaky toys are ideal
- Heavy chewers: Opt for tough rubber or nylon chews
- Easily bored dogs: Interactive or motion-activated toys add variety
Value Packs vs. Single Toys
Puppy owners or those with multiple dogs may benefit from multi-pack sets, which offer a range of toys at a lower cost. However, single toys often provide higher durability or specialized features. Decide if you want variety or a specific function.
Cleaning and Maintenance Considerations
Toys that are easy to clean help maintain hygiene and reduce odors. Dishwasher-safe or machine-washable options are convenient for busy owners. Treat-dispensing toys should be checked and cleaned regularly to prevent buildup.
Matching Toy Size and Strength to Your Dog
Always select toys that match your dog's size and chewing strength. Toys that are too small can be a choking hazard, while those too soft may be destroyed quickly by strong jaws. When in doubt, size up for safety.
Final Buying Advice
Choosing the right dog toy is about balancing your dog's needs with practical considerations like durability and cleanup. Start with your dog's play style and chewing habits, then narrow your options based on safety and maintenance.
- Match toy type to your dog's habits for best results
- Don't overbuy on novelty features if your dog prefers simple toys
- Prioritize safety and supervision with any new toy
- Pick easy-to-clean options for frequent use
- Remember that no toy is indestructible—inspect and replace as needed
FAQ For New Dog Toys
1. How do I choose the right size toy for my dog?
2. Are plush toys safe for heavy chewers?
3. How often should dog toys be cleaned?
4. What type of toy is best for keeping my dog busy when I'm away?
5. Can puppies use the same toys as adult dogs?
6. What should I do if my dog destroys a toy quickly?
