Finding the right treat for your small dog can be a challenge, especially with so many peanut butter options on the market. Owners want something that’s both tasty and safe, but it’s easy to get overwhelmed by ingredient lists, treat sizes, and different textures.
This guide breaks down the top peanut butter dog treats specifically suited for small dogs. We’ll cover crunchy biscuits, soft chews, and digestible alternatives, helping you choose the best treat for your pup’s size, dietary needs, and chewing preferences.
Top 5 Best Dog Treats Small Dogs Peanut Butter
To save you time and guesswork, we researched and compared top-rated best Dog Treats Small Dogs Peanut Butter products and selected the best options available today.
1. Old Mother Hubbard Mini Crunchy Peanut Butter Biscuits
Crunchy treats are a staple for small dogs who enjoy a satisfying bite and owners who want to support dental health. These biscuits offer a simple way to reward your dog while helping to keep teeth clean.
Old Mother Hubbard’s mini biscuits stand out for their classic recipe and oven-baked texture, making them ideal for small breeds or as training rewards. They’re best for dogs who prefer a firm, crunchy treat and owners who value natural ingredients.
- Mini size: Perfect for small mouths and easy portion control
- Oven-baked: Preserves natural flavors and provides a satisfying crunch
- No artificial preservatives: Made with simple, globally sourced ingredients
Compared to softer or larger treats, these biscuits prioritize tradition and texture, offering a straightforward, crunchy option. The tradeoff is that they may not suit dogs with sensitive teeth or those who prefer softer chews.
- Mini size for small dogs
- Crunchy texture aids dental health
- Natural ingredients
- No artificial preservatives
- Oven-baked for flavor
- Not suitable for dogs with dental issues
- May be too hard for some seniors
2. Buddy Biscuits Softies Peanut Butter Dog Treats
Soft treats are ideal for small dogs with sensitive teeth or those who simply prefer a gentler chew. They’re also a great choice for training, as they’re easy to break apart and quick to eat.
Buddy Biscuits Softies are baked fresh with simple ingredients, making them a good fit for owners who want a soft, wholesome treat without artificial additives. Their bite-sized shape is especially appealing for small and medium breeds.
- Soft texture: Gentle on teeth and easy to chew
- Simple ingredients: Free from corn, soy, and artificial flavors
- Oven-baked in the USA: Minimally processed for freshness
Unlike crunchy biscuits, these treats focus on softness and digestibility, which is great for picky eaters or dogs with dental sensitivities. The main tradeoff is that they may not help clean teeth as effectively as harder treats.
- Soft and chewy texture
- Easy to break for training
- No artificial flavors or colors
- Made in the USA
- Suitable for all life stages
- Less effective for dental cleaning
- May dry out if not sealed
3. SmartBones Smart Twist Sticks Peanut Butter Chews
Many small dogs love to chew, but rawhide can be difficult to digest and pose risks. Digestible chew alternatives offer a safer way to satisfy this instinct while providing a tasty reward.
SmartBones Smart Twist Sticks are rawhide-free and made with wholesome ingredients, making them a smart pick for owners seeking a safer chew. Their stick shape and peanut butter flavor appeal to dogs who enjoy gnawing and need a longer-lasting treat.
- Rawhide-free: Easier to digest and safer for most dogs
- Peanut butter, chicken, and vegetables: Flavorful and appealing
- Stick shape: Offers a satisfying chewing experience
Compared to traditional rawhide or crunchy biscuits, these chews focus on digestibility and safety. The tradeoff is that they may not last as long as harder rawhide chews for aggressive chewers.
- Rawhide-free formula
- Highly digestible
- Peanut butter and chicken flavor
- Helps maintain dental health
- Stick shape for chewing
- May not last for strong chewers
- Contains chicken for dogs with allergies
4. Milk-Bone Peanut Buttery Bites Soft Dog Treats
Soft, chewy treats are a go-to for small dogs who need something gentle on their teeth or who enjoy a quick, flavorful snack. They’re also handy for training and rewarding good behavior.
Milk-Bone Peanut Buttery Bites are made with real Jif peanut butter, offering a familiar flavor in a soft, easy-to-chew form. They’re a good match for dogs who love peanut butter and owners who want a convenient, mess-free treat.
- Soft and chewy: Suitable for dogs with sensitive teeth
- Made with Jif peanut butter: Delivers a recognizable, appealing aroma
- No artificial colors or fillers: High-quality ingredients for peace of mind
Compared to crunchy or chew-style treats, these bites focus on flavor and softness. The main tradeoff is that they may not provide the dental benefits of harder treats.
- Soft texture for easy chewing
- Made with real Jif peanut butter
- No artificial colors or fillers
- Convenient resealable bag
- Produced in the USA
- Not designed for dental cleaning
- May be too rich for some dogs
5. SmartBones Mini Peanut Butter Chews
Chew treats sized for small dogs offer a satisfying activity while helping to support dental health. Mini chews are especially important for smaller breeds that need treats they can handle safely.
SmartBones Mini Peanut Butter Chews are rawhide-free and made with a combination of peanut butter, chicken, and vegetables. Their mini size and bone shape make them a fun, digestible option for small dogs who love to chew.
- Mini bone shape: Designed for small mouths and easy handling
- Rawhide-free: Gentle on digestion and safe for most dogs
- Vitamin & mineral enriched: Supports overall health
Compared to larger chews or crunchy biscuits, these mini chews prioritize size and digestibility for small dogs. The tradeoff is that they may not last as long for dogs who are enthusiastic chewers.
- Mini size for small breeds
- Rawhide-free and digestible
- Peanut butter and chicken flavor
- Enriched with vitamins and minerals
- Supports dental health
- Shorter lasting for strong chewers
- Contains chicken for allergy-prone dogs
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Dog Treats for Small Dogs
Selecting the right peanut butter dog treat for your small dog involves more than just picking a flavor your pup likes. Owners must consider treat size, texture, digestibility, and ingredient quality, all while balancing convenience and health. Many buyers assume all treats are similar, but differences in chew type, calorie content, and packaging can make a big impact on your dog's enjoyment and well-being.
- Crunchy biscuits: Offer dental benefits and are easy to store, but may be too hard for some dogs
- Soft treats: Ideal for dogs with sensitive teeth or for training, though they may not clean teeth as effectively
- Digestible chews: Provide a safe alternative to rawhide and satisfy chewing instincts, but may not last as long for aggressive chewers
- Bulk options: Great for multi-dog households or frequent treating, but check treat size to ensure suitability for small breeds
- Ingredient quality: Look for treats with simple, natural ingredients and avoid unnecessary fillers or artificial additives
- Calorie content: Important for training or frequent rewards to avoid overfeeding
- Flavor variety: Can help keep picky eaters interested, but some dogs may have sensitivities to certain proteins or additives
- Packaging differences: May affect freshness and storage; resealable bags are often more convenient
- Common misunderstanding: Assuming all treats are equally healthy—always check ingredient lists and calorie counts
Crunchy vs. Soft Treats: Which to Choose?
Crunchy treats are great for supporting dental health and providing a satisfying bite, but they may not be suitable for dogs with dental issues or very small mouths. Soft treats are easier to chew and ideal for training, but they may not offer the same dental benefits. Choose based on your dog's chewing ability and your training needs.
Rawhide-Free Chews for Safer Snacking
Rawhide-free chews, like those from SmartBones, offer a safer and more digestible alternative to traditional rawhide. These are especially important for small dogs, who may struggle with harder chews. However, they may not last as long for dogs who are persistent chewers.
Bulk and Variety Packs: When Quantity Matters
If you have multiple dogs or treat frequently, bulk options like Amazon Basics or Milk-Bone’s large boxes can be cost-effective. Variety packs keep treat time interesting but check the size of each treat to ensure it’s appropriate for your dog.
Ingredient Simplicity and Calorie Control
For dogs with sensitivities or owners concerned about overfeeding, treats with simple, natural ingredients and low calorie counts are best. Nutro’s low-calorie treats are especially suited for training sessions where frequent rewards are needed.
Packaging and Storage Considerations
Resealable packaging helps keep treats fresh, especially for soft or bulk treats. If you prefer to switch up treat flavors, look for brands that offer variety in packaging and flavors.
Final Buying Advice
Choosing the right peanut butter treat for your small dog comes down to understanding your dog’s needs and preferences. Consider texture, size, and ingredient quality before making a decision.
- Match treat size to your dog’s mouth and chewing ability
- Choose soft treats for training or dogs with dental sensitivities
- Opt for crunchy or chewable treats to support dental health
- Check ingredient lists for artificial additives or fillers
- Don’t overbuy bulk treats if your dog is picky or you want to rotate flavors
FAQ For Dog Treats Small Dogs Peanut Butter
1. Are peanut butter dog treats safe for all small dogs?
2. How do I choose the right treat size for my small dog?
3. Do crunchy treats help clean my dog’s teeth?
4. Are soft treats better for training?
5. What should I avoid in peanut butter dog treats?
6. How should I store dog treats to keep them fresh?
James Vega
Related Posts
- Best Dog Teeth Cleaning Treat: Top Picks
- Top 10 Best Large Elk Antlers For Dogs
- Top 7 Best Antler Bones For Dogs
- Top 6 Best Golden Rewards Dog Treats
- Best Busy Bones Large Dog: Top Picks
- Top 6 Best Dog Health Bars
- Top 6 Best Dog Chews For Heavy Chewers
- Best Milkbone Dog Treats Large Breed: Top Picks
- Best Dog Valentine Treats: Top Picks
- Best Rachel Ray Treats: Top Picks
- Top 10 Best Honest Kitchen Fish Skins
- Top 8 Best Dog Chew Toys For Strong Chewers
- Top 7 Best Top Chews Naturals Chicken Jerky Dog Treats
- Best Doggy Treats For Small Dogs: Top Picks
- Best Meatball Dog Treats: Top Picks
- Best Puppy Chews Long Lasting: Top Picks
- Top 6 Best Dog Trests
- Best Christmas Dog Treats: Top Picks
- Top 10 Best Rawhide Bones For Medium Dogs
- Best Wag Freeze Dried Dog Treats: Top Picks