Cleaning up after your dog is a daily reality for every pet owner, but traditional plastic bags can leave a lasting impact on the environment. Many dog owners are looking for a way to keep their hands clean and sidewalks tidy without contributing to landfill waste or microplastics.
Compostable dog poop bags offer a practical, earth-friendly solution. In this guide, you’ll find the best options for every type of dog and owner, from certified compostable picks to extra-thick, leak-proof designs. We break down the real differences, so you can choose a bag that fits your routine and your values.
Top 6 Compostable Dog Poop Bags
Choosing the right Compostable Dog Poop Bags can be confusing, so we compared the most popular options and narrowed it down to the best ones for you.
1. Earth Rated Poop Bags Extra Thick Refill Rolls
Dog owners want a reliable way to clean up after their pets without worrying about leaks or mess. Choosing a sturdy, eco-conscious bag can make daily walks simpler and more responsible.
Earth Rated's extra thick poop bags are a strong choice for those who want durability and a reduced environmental footprint. These bags are ideal for anyone seeking a dependable, easy-to-use option that also incorporates recycled materials.
- Certified 65% post-consumer recycled plastic: Reduces landfill waste and gives new life to existing materials
- Extra long and strong (13" x 9"): Keeps hands clean and fits all dog sizes
- "3 Bags Left" sticker: Provides a helpful reminder before you run out
Compared to typical bags, Earth Rated prioritizes recycled content and leak-proof strength. The main tradeoff is that these are not fully compostable, but they are a major step up from standard plastic alternatives.
- Made with recycled plastic
- Extra thick and leak-proof
- Easy to tear from roll
- Fits standard dispensers
- Handy low-bag reminder
- Not fully compostable
- Scented option not specified
2. Codirom Certified Compostable Dog Poop Bags 270 Count
For pet owners committed to minimizing their environmental impact, finding a truly compostable poop bag is essential. Many bags claim to be eco-friendly but don't break down fully or quickly enough.
Codirom's certified compostable bags are designed for those who want assurance that their bags will decompose in home composting conditions. They're a great fit for eco-conscious owners who want a straightforward, landfill-friendly solution.
- Home compostable to strict standards: Certified to TV AUSTRIA, ASTM D6400, EN13432, and NF T51-800:2015
- Made from corn, vegetable oil, and PBAT: Uses renewable, plant-based materials
- 270 bags per pack (18 rolls): Suits both small and large dogs, fits standard dispensers
Unlike many alternatives, Codirom focuses on verified compostability and quick breakdown. The main tradeoff is a shorter shelf life, so only buy what you can use within 10 months.
- Certified home compostable
- Plant-based materials
- Easy to separate and open
- Odor control
- Fits standard dispensers
- Shelf life about 12 months
- Must store away from heat
3. Greener Walker Extra Thick Compostable Poop Bags 540 Pack
Picking up after your dog shouldn't mean running out of bags or worrying about leaks. Owners with multiple dogs or busy routines need a reliable, cost-effective supply.
Greener Walker's 540-count pack is ideal for families, dog walkers, or anyone who wants to stock up and save. The extra thick, leak-proof design makes cleanup easy and worry-free.
- 540 bags (36 rolls): Lasts up to 9 months with regular use
- Corn starch blend material: More eco-friendly than standard plastics
- Paper packaging and roll cores: Reduces plastic waste throughout
Compared to smaller packs, this option prioritizes quantity and value. The tradeoff is that you should monitor shelf life to ensure bags remain effective.
- Very large quantity per pack
- Extra thick and leak-proof
- Eco-friendly materials
- Fits standard dispensers
- Paper packaging
- May expire if unused
- Not certified home compostable
4. G.A.S 100% Home Compostable Dog Poop Bags 10% Charity
Dog owners who want to make a positive impact beyond their own backyard often look for products that give back. Combining eco-friendly materials with charitable support adds extra value to daily routines.
G.A.S compostable bags are perfect for those who want a certified, plant-based bag and appreciate that 10% of profits support animal welfare. They're well-suited for eco-conscious owners who value both sustainability and social responsibility.
- 100% home compostable (ASTM D6400, EN 13432, NF T51-800): Breaks down fully in home compost
- Made from cornstarch, BPAT, and edible glycerin: No petroleum-based plastics
- Box and reel from recycled cardboard: Zero-waste packaging
Compared to typical bags, G.A.S stands out for its ethical sourcing and charitable donations. The tradeoff is a slightly higher price point for the added social benefit.
- Certified home compostable
- Plant-based ingredients
- Supports animal charities
- Recycled packaging
- Fits all dispensers
- Higher cost per bag
- Unscented only
5. Natuural Certified Compostable Poop Bags 270 Count
Managing pet waste can be unpleasant, especially when odor is a concern. Owners who want a compostable solution often struggle to find bags that also help mask smells.
Natuural's compostable bags offer a light corn scent to lock in odors, making them a good fit for those who want both eco-friendliness and a more pleasant cleanup experience. Suitable for all dog sizes and even other messes like cat litter or diapers.
- Certified compostable (ASTM D6400, EN13432, NF T51-800:2015): Plant-based and breaks down in compost
- Light corn scent: Helps control odors without heavy perfumes
- 270 bags (18 rolls): Practical for multi-pet households
Compared to unscented alternatives, Natuural prioritizes odor control and compostability. The tradeoff is the need to use bags within their 12-month shelf life.
- Certified compostable
- Light corn scent
- Multi-use for pets and more
- Fits standard dispensers
- Good value pack
- Shelf life about 12 months
- Scent may not suit all users
6. RMancipate Green Lavender Scented Poo Bags 270 Pack
For pet owners who want a pleasant-smelling cleanup, scented bags can make daily walks more enjoyable. Many compostable options are unscented, leaving fewer choices for those sensitive to odors.
RMancipate's lavender-scented bags combine compostable materials with extra thickness, making them a good pick for those who want both odor control and reliability. The included holder adds convenience for on-the-go use.
- Lavender scent: Helps mask unpleasant odors during use
- Extra thick and leak-proof: Keeps hands clean and safe
- 270 bags (18 rolls), includes holder: Enough for months of walks
Compared to unscented bags, this option prioritizes fragrance and ease of use. The tradeoff is that the scent may not appeal to everyone, and compostability details are less specific.
- Lavender scented
- Extra thick design
- Includes bag holder
- Made from corn starch
- Recycled packaging
- Compostability not fully detailed
- Scent may be strong for some
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Compostable Dog Poop Bags
Compostable dog poop bags are a practical upgrade for eco-conscious pet owners, but not all bags are created equal. The main challenge is balancing environmental responsibility with everyday convenience—buyers must consider compostability, durability, odor control, and pack size. Many people assume all "green" bags are the same, but certifications, materials, and real-world usability can vary widely.
- Certified compostable vs. recycled content: Some bags are fully home compostable, while others use recycled plastic for reduced landfill impact
- Scented vs. unscented: Options range from light corn or lavender scents to completely unscented for sensitive users
- Pack size and value: Large packs offer better value but may expire before use; smaller packs suit occasional or single-dog households
- Bag thickness and leak-proofing: Extra thick bags keep hands clean but may be less flexible; thinner bags can tear more easily
- Included accessories: Some packs come with a bag holder for added convenience
- Shelf life and storage: Compostable bags often have a 10–12 month shelf life and need to be stored away from heat
- Common misunderstanding: Not all "biodegradable" bags are truly compostable or break down quickly in home compost
Choosing Between Compostable and Recycled Bags
The biggest decision is whether to prioritize full compostability or recycled content. Compostable bags break down in home or industrial compost, but require careful storage and timely use. Recycled plastic bags are sturdier and last longer, but won't decompose as quickly.
- Compostable bags: Best for owners with access to composting or who want minimal environmental impact
- Recycled content bags: Good for those who want durability and a greener alternative to standard plastic
Scented vs. Unscented Bags
Odor control is important for many pet owners. Scented bags, such as those with lavender or corn, help mask unpleasant smells. However, some users prefer unscented bags to avoid irritation or allergies.
- Scented bags: Provide a fresher experience during walks
- Unscented bags: Suitable for sensitive noses or multi-use cleanup
Pack Size and Shelf Life
Bulk packs offer better value but can expire if not used quickly, especially for compostable bags. Smaller packs are ideal for single-dog households or infrequent use.
- Large packs: Cost-effective for multi-dog families or frequent walkers
- Small packs: Reduce waste and ensure bags are used before expiration
Accessories and Convenience
Some products include a bag holder or use packaging made from recycled materials. These extras can make daily walks easier and further reduce your environmental footprint.
- Bag holders: Add convenience for on-the-go use
- Recycled packaging: Minimizes waste beyond the bag itself
Final Buying Advice
Choosing the right compostable dog poop bag comes down to your routine, environmental priorities, and sensitivity to scents. Don't overbuy if you have a single dog or walk infrequently, as compostable bags can expire. Look for certifications if true compostability matters to you, and consider added features like scent or included holders for extra convenience.
- Match pack size to your usage to avoid expired bags
- Check for compostability certifications if you plan to compost at home
- Choose scented or unscented based on your preference
- Consider recycled content for durability if composting isn't an option
- Store bags in a cool, dry place to maximize shelf life
FAQ For Compostable Dog Poop Bags
1. What is the difference between compostable and biodegradable dog poop bags?
2. How should I store compostable dog poop bags?
3. Are scented poop bags safe for all dogs?
4. Can compostable dog poop bags be used in any dispenser?
5. Do compostable bags break down in landfills?
6. What certifications should I look for in compostable bags?
James Vega
Related Posts
- Top 6 Best In Show Dog Movie Scenes
- Best Dog Stain Removers: Top Picks
- Top 7 Best Supplements For Dog Dry Skin
- Best Dog Harness Seat Belts: Top Picks
- Best Home Remedies For Dog Hot Spots: Top Picks
- Best Dog Allergy Supplements: Top Picks
- Best Dogs For Truck Drivers: Top Picks
- Best Products For Horse Tail Growth: Top Picks
- Top 6 Best Dog Lotions For Dry, Itchy Skin
- Best Dog Pajamas: Top Picks
- Top 10 Best Dog Knee Braces For Luxating Patella
- Top 8 Best Dog Gps & Training Collars
- Top 7 Best Dog Boots For Running
- Top 10 Best Cat Dander Removers
- Top 7 Best Guard Dog For Woman
- Best Cat Deshedders: Top Picks
- Best Airtag Holders For Dogs: Top Picks
- Top 6 Best Medicine For Dog Anxiety
- Best Dog Prong Collars: Top Picks
- Best Pitbull Dog Breeds: Top Picks