Finding the right chew treat for small dogs can be challenging, especially when you want something safe, natural, and long-lasting. Many owners worry about rawhide risks, artificial ingredients, and treats that are too tough or too large for smaller breeds.
Nature Gnaws offers a range of bully sticks and chew options designed specifically for small dogs and light chewers. In this guide, we compare the best Nature Gnaws bully sticks, highlighting differences in thickness, pack size, and chew type to help you pick the safest and most satisfying option for your pup.
Top 10 Best Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks For Small Dogs
We analyzed the top brands and best-selling products in the Best Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks For Small Dogs category to bring you a carefully curated list of recommendations.
1. Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks
Some puppies are gentle chewers and need a treat that's not too tough but still provides lasting enjoyment. Many chews are either too hard or break apart quickly, making them unsuitable for light chewers or small breeds.
Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks are single-ingredient, natural beef chews that are easy for small or gentle chewers to enjoy. They're rawhide-free, low-odor, and help support dental health, making them a great fit for puppies who need a milder option.
- Single Ingredient: No fillers or artificial additives
- Extra Thin Size: Ideal for small mouths and gentle chewers
- Natural Dental Benefits: Helps reduce plaque and tartar
Compared to thicker or synthetic chews, these sticks focus on simplicity and ease of chewing. The main limitation is that they may not last as long for more determined chewers.
- Ideal for small or gentle chewers
- Single-ingredient simplicity
- Supports dental health
- Low odor
- Grain and gluten free
- Not for aggressive chewers
- Can finish quickly
2. Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks 25 Count
For owners who want to keep their small dogs occupied and happy on a regular basis, a larger pack of bully sticks offers convenience and value. Bully sticks are a safe alternative to rawhide and help with dental hygiene.
This 25-count pack of extra thin bully sticks is perfect for multi-dog households or anyone who likes to have plenty of chews on hand. It's designed for light chewers and puppies who need a gentle, satisfying treat.
- Large 25-count pack for frequent treating or multiple dogs
- Extra thin size ensures easy chewing for small breeds
- Grain-free and gluten-free for sensitive stomachs
Compared to smaller packs, this option prioritizes quantity and convenience. The tradeoff is that extra thin sticks may not last as long per chew session.
- Great value for bulk buyers
- Ideal for frequent treating
- Easy for small dogs to handle
- Natural and digestible
- Low odor
- Shorter lasting per stick
- Not for strong chewers
3. Nature Gnaws Super Skinny Bully Sticks 15 Count
Some small dogs and puppies need an even thinner chew to enjoy safely and comfortably. Bully sticks in a super skinny size can be the perfect solution for very light chewers or those with delicate teeth.
This 15-count pack of super skinny bully sticks is tailored for the smallest mouths and gentlest chewers. It's a great option for teething puppies or senior dogs who need a softer treat.
- Super skinny diameter for the gentlest chewing experience
- Pack of 15 offers a good supply for regular use
- Rawhide-free and natural to support healthy digestion
Compared to regular thin bully sticks, this ultra-thin version is easier to chew but will be consumed more quickly. It's best for dogs who can't handle thicker treats.
- Easiest to chew for tiny dogs
- Gentle on teeth and gums
- Good for teething puppies
- Natural beef ingredient
- No rawhide
- Very short-lasting
- Not for moderate chewers
4. Nature Gnaws Small Bully Sticks 5 Count
If you only give your dog treats occasionally or want to try a small quantity before committing, a compact pack of bully sticks is a practical choice. Bully sticks help keep dogs busy and support oral health.
This 5-count pack is ideal for owners who want to reward their small or medium dog every so often without buying in bulk. It's suitable for light chewers and puppies who need a manageable treat.
- Convenient 5-count pack for occasional use
- Thin size designed for small and medium dogs
- Natural beef pizzle with no artificial additives
Compared to larger packs, this option prioritizes flexibility and freshness. The main tradeoff is a higher cost per stick if used frequently.
- Good for trying out bully sticks
- Easy to store and use
- Natural and simple ingredients
- Supports dental hygiene
- Not cost-effective for daily use
- Limited supply per purchase
5. Nature Gnaws Thin Bully Sticks Mixed Thickness 8oz
Dogs can have different chewing preferences, and a mixed thickness pack offers variety to keep things interesting. Bully sticks in assorted sizes can help owners find the right fit for their dog's needs.
This 8oz bag includes thin bully sticks in various thicknesses, making it a versatile choice for small dogs who like some variety or for households with more than one pet. It's a flexible option for light chewers.
- Mixed thicknesses provide different chewing experiences
- 8oz bag offers multiple treats in one purchase
- Single-ingredient, high-protein formula for health-conscious owners
Compared to single-size packs, this variety pack prioritizes flexibility but may include sticks that are too thin or too thick for some dogs.
- Offers variety in chew size
- Good for picky eaters
- Supports dental health
- Natural and grain-free
- Inconsistent stick sizes
- Some pieces may not suit all dogs
6. Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Pork Bully Sticks 15 Count
Some dogs have sensitivities to beef or simply prefer a different protein source. Pork bully sticks provide a natural, single-ingredient alternative for small dogs who need variety in their treats.
This 15-count pack of extra thin pork bully sticks is designed for light chewers and those with beef allergies. It's a good option for owners looking to diversify their dog's treat selection.
- Made from pork pizzle for dogs with beef sensitivities
- Extra thin size for easy chewing by small breeds
- Rawhide-free and low-odor for safety and convenience
Compared to beef options, this pork version prioritizes alternative protein but may not appeal to all dogs' tastes.
- Alternative protein source
- Good for dogs with beef allergies
- Easy to chew for small dogs
- Natural and simple ingredients
- Flavor may not suit all dogs
- Limited to pork protein
7. Nature Gnaws Braided Bully Sticks 3 Count
Braided bully sticks offer a more complex chewing experience, which can help keep dogs engaged and occupied for longer. They are often chosen for their durability and unique texture.
This 3-count pack of braided bully sticks is a good fit for small to medium dogs who enjoy a tougher, more challenging chew. It's a natural, high-protein treat with no artificial additives.
- Braided design increases chew time and engagement
- High-protein, single-ingredient beef for nutritional value
- Rawhide-free and oven-baked for safety and taste
Compared to standard sticks, braided options prioritize longevity and texture but may be too tough for the smallest or gentlest chewers.
- Longer-lasting chew
- Engaging braided texture
- Natural beef ingredient
- No artificial additives
- May be too tough for tiny dogs
- Only three per pack
8. Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks Mixed Thickness 8oz
Some small dogs are surprisingly strong chewers and need a more robust treat to keep them satisfied. Mixed thickness bully sticks can offer a tougher challenge and longer-lasting enjoyment.
This 8oz bag contains bully sticks of varying thickness, making it suitable for teething puppies and more determined chewers. It's a natural, rawhide-free option for owners who want to keep their dogs safely occupied.
- Mixed thicknesses cater to different chewing strengths
- 8-10 sticks per bag for extended use
- Single-ingredient beef supports healthy digestion
Compared to extra thin options, this pack prioritizes durability and chew time but may be too tough for very gentle chewers.
- Good for stronger chewers
- Variety of stick sizes
- Supports dental health
- Natural and grain-free
- Some sticks may be too large
- Not ideal for the smallest dogs
9. Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks Mixed Thickness 1Lb
Households with multiple dogs or those who want to stock up on treats will benefit from a larger bag of bully sticks. Mixed thicknesses ensure there's something for every dog's preference.
This 1lb bag contains approximately 16-20 sticks, making it a practical choice for busy homes or frequent treat-giving. It's designed for small to medium dogs who enjoy a range of chew sizes.
- Large 1lb bag offers excellent supply for multi-dog families
- Mixed thicknesses to suit various chewing styles
- Natural beef pizzle with no artificial ingredients
Compared to smaller packs, this option prioritizes quantity and variety but may be overwhelming for single-dog households or very small dogs.
- Great for multi-dog homes
- Plenty of sticks per bag
- Variety of sizes included
- Natural and digestible
- May be too much for one dog
- Some sticks could be too thick
9. Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks Mixed Thickness 1Lb
Households with multiple dogs or those who want to stock up on treats will benefit from a larger bag of bully sticks. Mixed thicknesses ensure there's something for every dog's preference.
This 1lb bag contains approximately 16-20 sticks, making it a practical choice for busy homes or frequent treat-giving. It's designed for small to medium dogs who enjoy a range of chew sizes.
- Large 1lb bag offers excellent supply for multi-dog families
- Mixed thicknesses to suit various chewing styles
- Natural beef pizzle with no artificial ingredients
Compared to smaller packs, this option prioritizes quantity and variety but may be overwhelming for single-dog households or very small dogs.
- Great for multi-dog homes
- Plenty of sticks per bag
- Variety of sizes included
- Natural and digestible
- May be too much for one dog
- Some sticks could be too thick
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Bully Sticks for Small Dogs
Bully sticks are a popular chew treat for small dogs, but not all options are created equal. Buyers must consider thickness, protein source, pack size, and chew style to ensure the right fit for their pet. Many assume all bully sticks are the same, but differences in size, composition, and variety can impact safety, enjoyment, and value.
- Extra thin vs. mixed thickness: Extra thin sticks are gentler and easier for small or senior dogs, while mixed thickness packs offer more variety and can suit multiple chewing strengths.
- Beef vs. pork options: Most bully sticks are made from beef, but pork alternatives are available for dogs with sensitivities or taste preferences.
- Braided vs. standard sticks: Braided sticks last longer and provide a more challenging chew, but may be too tough for the smallest or gentlest dogs.
- Variety packs: These include different types of chews (bully sticks, tendons, tripe) to keep dogs engaged and help owners discover their pet's favorites.
- Pack size matters: Larger packs offer better value for frequent treaters or multi-dog homes, while small packs are best for occasional use or trying new products.
- Rawhide-free and natural: All options here are rawhide-free and made from single or limited ingredients, but always check for grain-free and low-odor features if your dog is sensitive.
- Common misunderstanding: Many buyers overestimate how long bully sticks will last for strong chewers—thinner sticks are best for light chewers, while mixed or braided options suit tougher jaws.
Choosing the Right Thickness and Chew Style
Selecting the right thickness and chew style is crucial for your dog's safety and enjoyment. Extra thin and super skinny sticks are best for puppies, seniors, and very small breeds, while mixed thickness or braided sticks offer more challenge and last longer for stronger chewers.
- Extra thin and super skinny: Gentle, easy to chew, ideal for delicate mouths
- Mixed thickness: Provides options for different chewing strengths in one pack
- Braided: Engages dogs who need a tougher, longer-lasting treat
Protein Source: Beef vs. Pork
Most bully sticks are made from beef, but pork options are available for dogs with allergies or taste preferences. Choosing the right protein can help avoid digestive issues and keep your dog interested in their treats.
- Beef: The standard choice, widely accepted by most dogs
- Pork: Good alternative for dogs with beef sensitivities
Pack Size and Value Considerations
Pack size affects both convenience and cost. Bulk packs are ideal for frequent treat-giving or multi-dog households, while smaller packs suit occasional use or first-time buyers.
- Bulk packs: More economical for regular use
- Small packs: Lower upfront cost, less waste if your dog is picky
Variety Packs for Picky Eaters
If your dog gets bored easily or you're unsure which treat they'll prefer, a variety pack is a smart choice. These packs combine bully sticks with other chews like tendons and tripe twists to keep things interesting.
- Multiple textures and flavors help prevent boredom
- Good for discovering new favorites
Final Buying Advice
Choosing the right bully stick comes down to your dog's size, chewing habits, and any dietary sensitivities. Don't assume all sticks are the same—pay attention to thickness, protein source, and pack size to match your dog's needs.
- Match thickness to your dog's chewing strength to avoid frustration or waste
- Consider protein sensitivities before choosing beef or pork
- Buy in bulk only if you'll use them before they go stale
- Try a variety pack if your dog is picky or new to bully sticks
- Avoid overbuying extra thin sticks for aggressive chewers—they won't last
FAQ For Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks For Small Dogs
1. Are Nature Gnaws bully sticks safe for small dogs?
2. How do I choose the right thickness for my dog?
3. What is the difference between beef and pork bully sticks?
4. How long does a bully stick last for a small dog?
5. Are these bully sticks rawhide-free?
6. Can I give my dog a bully stick every day?
7. What should I do if my dog swallows a large piece?
James Vega
Related Posts
- Best Dog Teeth Cleaning Treat: Top Picks
- Top 10 Best Large Elk Antlers For Dogs
- Top 7 Best Antler Bones For Dogs
- Top 6 Best Golden Rewards Dog Treats
- Best Busy Bones Large Dog: Top Picks
- Top 6 Best Dog Health Bars
- Top 6 Best Dog Chews For Heavy Chewers
- Best Milkbone Dog Treats Large Breed: Top Picks
- Best Dog Valentine Treats: Top Picks
- Best Rachel Ray Treats: Top Picks
- Top 10 Best Honest Kitchen Fish Skins
- Top 8 Best Dog Chew Toys For Strong Chewers
- Top 7 Best Top Chews Naturals Chicken Jerky Dog Treats
- Best Doggy Treats For Small Dogs: Top Picks
- Best Meatball Dog Treats: Top Picks
- Best Puppy Chews Long Lasting: Top Picks
- Top 6 Best Dog Trests
- Best Christmas Dog Treats: Top Picks
- Top 10 Best Rawhide Bones For Medium Dogs
- Best Wag Freeze Dried Dog Treats: Top Picks